ŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻŻ
Dear Young,
I hope you
can find 12 atheists willing to respond, even if dozens get to read your
request. We have seen such before, most of us, and have learned to regard
them with suspicion. Most are from people looking to bait us, or for
information to use against us in their own agendas. Truth be told, many of
us don't know the answer to some of your questions, as all that is
required to be an atheist is absence of god-related belief. Atheism is
about what we are *not*, not what we are, and while that generally means
only that we are *not* religious, that's all it says about us, and may be
all we have, as a "demographic", in common.
__________________________________________
>-
>- Survey
>- What is your name?
Lloyd
Harrison Whitling,
http://www.atheistlloyd.com . If you are serious and this is not a
hoax or bait, you will find other information there, and links to other
atheist sites all over the world, enough information to keep you busy at
research the rest of your life.
>- What is you(r) gender?
male
>-
>- How old are you? 70
>-
>- How is fact determined?
A 'fact' is
not about what people believe, no matter how many of them do so. A "fact"
is dependable information as determined by testing and physically
demonstrating its accuracy, usefulness for whatever tasks it pertains to,
verified by other people in other places and times, that enables accurate
predictions to be made about whatever it pertains to. Testability and
factuality stroll hand in hand.
>- What is joy?
You will
find that I am an unusual atheist in that I am a clergy person for
Spiritual Humanism. Spiritual Humanism is exactly the same as Secular
Humanism, but for our interest in nurturing the progressive side of human
existence. Joy results not only from personal accomplishment, but also
from the successes of others who may be close to you, or merely
acquaintances. It has nothing to do with gods, angels or such, but is an
emotion that emanates in all the different ways of which a healthy human
being is capable.
>- Is joy always temporary,
or can it be eternal/long lasting?
Joy is best
experienced in waves, the peaks of which are best experienced after one
has "earned" it through personal or team accomplishment. "Permanent" joy
becomes pain, as a painful distraction that occupies one's mind and
renders all efforts to overcome it as futile. Think of the most fun thing
you get to do, and then about being made to do that with no rest forever,
with no chance for advancement to the next level.
>- What is pain? Are
physical and emotional pain connected?
Pain is
nature's way of warning animals against something, to get us to stop doing
something, wanting something, going someplace, or to teach us that
something we did was wrong. In practical hedonism, pleasure and pain play
against each other as reward and punishment so that we can learn to be
moral human beings. By experiencing both, healthy-minded, reasoning human
beings (and other animals) learn empathy and compassion. The experience of
ongoing pain in a goal-oriented task is a normal price to pay for the
heightened pleasure and joy that successful accomplishment is hoped to
bring.
That, by the
way, is not different from the Heaven/Hell scenario that some religions
teach, except that practical hedonists can expereince their rewards in the
here and now, whereas the religious experience the pain in the here and
now in exchange for empty promises of "eternal" (painful) joy after death.
>- What is faith? Is it good
to have? Is it a synonym for hope, or is
>- there a difference? If so
what is the difference?
Faith is akin to confidence: In
what does one place confidence?
Atheists
realize that we are responsible for our accomplishments and failures, and
so must place confidence in ourselves to earn our rewards and realize
whatever pain results for our own failures. The only alternative to that
is to blame others, or to expect others to to provide (whether it be
truths, nourishment, housing or what). In the communist political
religion, for example, the expectation for "others" to perform led to the
downfall of most communal experiments. In the Arabic religions, and
others, the expectation of authorized authorities to be truthful and
honest has led to a divisiveness in the religious ranks that could not
have occurred had they been provided with a reliable primary source of
information.
>- How has your family
influenced you in your atheist decision? (Do
>- they support you, or did
you come to this decision on your own?
>- Has it caused family
issues?)
Among
others, my family did influence me to adopt an atheistic philosophy by
proselytizing to me about their religious beliefs. I found them to be
untenable and diabolical, and that I could only adopt them as a complete
hypocrite. Family issues? I believe their religious heckling directly
caused my youngest brother to become insane because he could not escape
from them the way I did. Such issues as that led me to author The
Complete Universe of Memes, which ought to provide religious people
with plenty of insights about the direct harmfulness religions cause, and
what is behind that to drive it onward.
ISBN 0595244297, read about it at
http://www.atheistlloyd.com/AboutMybooks/index.html . If your interest
in such questions as these is serious, I (of course) recommend you to
purchase a copy and read through it several times, as you may find it
rather heady, definitely not light reading. If there is a god,
understanding this book will provide you with insights about demonstrating
that, and about the true nature of deities. You may not like what you
discover, but truth is not a matter of preference, but about what is real.
>- Why dont you believe in
God? Did you ever believe in God?
Yes, I am an
apostate, and may have remained a Christian were it not for wanting to
know whatever is true the best way I could discover that. I believe that
basic, internalized honor and self-respect, along with the constant
prodding of the religious herders, drives thoughtful honest people to
abandon their religious upbringing.
>- Can you prove God does
not exist? or is that a matter of faith with you?
It is not my
duty to disprove existence of the god named God, nor any other god. It is
the duty of those who would convince me to describe which of the gods they
have given the name God, and to demonstrate the reality of that in some
way that I can verify. Otherwise, I cannot believe without knowing
exactly what I am being asked to accept in some real (not anecdotal)
fashion. If you do not know what you believe in so you can describe and
demonstrate it, you are being very careless with the life you are living.
Why throw that away on a whim or a guess?
>- Do you consider atheism
to go hand in hand with evolution? Do you
>- believe in evolution? If
not, what do you believe?
Evolution is
not something to believe in, as it meets all the requirements for
factuality already set forth. The only way atheism and evolution go "hand
in hand" is that both result from the quest for testable, dependable
answers that enable accurate predictability in ways that no alternatives
can. One does not have to "believe in" evolution to demonstrate it as
being the most honest of all the alternative theories and hypotheses.
>- What is truth?
Truth is
nothing more than a goal that enterprising mankind struggles toward. It is
easier to say what truth is not than what it may be:
Truth is not
a "thing". Truth is not something somebody owns the only one of.
Truth is not an emanation from the past, but a condition of studied future
knowledge that humans may share to edify common understanding about
various facets of our existence. Truth is about information, but not
anecdotal tales from unverifiable sources about impossible events that
left no evidence of their occurrence. Truth is the result of trial and
error and the acknowledgement of what went wrong as much, even more than,
of what went right and why. Truth is the ever increasing accuracy of the
human pool of knowledge that enables greater certainty and predictability
inherent to any assemblage of facts.
Truth is
useful knowledge well understood. Anything else is moot, errors, guesses,
opinions, or outright lies. That, in a nutshell, will lead to apostasy for
any honest person who dares to use it to test his or her own beliefs, and
I believe that is why religions typically condemn atheism as an evil they
must banish from their presence.