Lloyd Harrison Whitling's WebSite, THE NAKED TRUTH.

 

 

 

 

This page is from http://www.atheistlloyd.com/Debunking/PHarvey.html

That Message Accredited to Paul Harvey

Debunking by Lloyd Harrison Whitling

SML98 Hit Counter

The "message" follows this:

Another hoax, right? I am surprised when I read facts-free messages so full of red herrings, ad hominems, lies, and argumentum ad populem that other people let these writers get away with it.

But, then, the educational level in the USA has been diminishing in comparison to other countries. No wonder we are going downhill: People such as the writer of this are our self-proclaimed leaders; they will remain in their positions for so long as they have followers.

When people put questionable words into Paul Harvey's mouth, they should at least have the decency to tell us when he said them, and where, so they can be verified. We have no idea which Paul Harvey was claimed to have said all these things.

And then, the inevitable attack against atheists is added to it, by a writer who once more admonishes his readers about how sick and tired they are of atheists actually standing up against the constant barrage of attacks against us. The rant against prayer is taken out of context and borders on being a lie: NO ONE is forcing Xians to stop praying or take down their idols except at government-sponsored occasions where an authority figure is leading the way or making the displays. If someone violates your right to pray outside that limitation, they are wrong. You can take them to those same courts you complain about, and have your rights asserted. People have done that and been successful. No atheists are suing anybody about their religious actions outside of governmental property or governmental events, as we recognize your constitutional rights are the same as ours. To perpetuate that myth is to continue to betray the trust of those who depend on your veracity for their information. Stop lying!

If Seventh day Adventists are looking at atheists as being the cause of decline in our country, they are being very foolish. We who are active can show them to whom they will eventually have to give up their Sabbath, and it is not us.

We don't care what day you guys worship.

We don't care what you believe in.

We are not the ones with whom your argument about biblical edicts gets perpetuated— unless you go out of your way to accuse us unfairly and about untrue claims, or to try to force your beliefs onto us. America's secular founding fathers warned us about how easily freedoms get lost from people who are not paying attention. It is apparent that we must pay not only good attention, but also attention to the right things.

Look to the Sunday church-goers, who harbor such people as George W. Bush and all the Bush clan, Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, Tom De Lay, Bill Frist, and the tribe of Intelligent Designers who are struggling to institute unconstitutional and immoral doctrines into law. There are those, and more. Those are the ones I warned about a few years ago. They have lived down to the standards they have set ever since then, and continue to strive for the institutionalizing of their agendas and to seek a uniform doctrine under which all of us will one day live if they can keep the rest of us distracted enough to not catch on to what they really are doing.

As for Paul Harvey, I doubted he said all the message attributed to him years ago when I first saw it, and still doubt that today. Don't forget, I, too, am a member of a minority, but belong to the one that will consider actual evidence when it does get presented. Angry words and belligerent antisecular bluster mean very little. I am not the kind of person who demands that you should go to church on Sunday. In fact, I don't care if you never go at all!

 

[:

[: -----Original Message-----

[: From: (removed to protect the perpetrator)]

[: Sent: Thursday, September 29, 2005 7:27 AM

[: To: lwhitling@lloydwhitling.com

[: Subject: Fwd: Fwd: Paul Harvey and Prayer

[:

[: It's Interesting that as an SDA Minister I agree with 99% of this email,

[: but I also hear the tyrany of the majority that is prophecied about in

[: the Spirit of Prophecy. The USA will eventually do just what Paul Harvey

[: says, and the disasters befalling our country will be the reason Sunday

[: worship will be forced upon the minority. Sunday observance is one of

[: the institutions they are talking about. It will appear to make sense, and

[: we will appear unreasonable. Stand for the right, even if the heavens fall!

[: The winds of change are blowing, and I can feel the heat of the dragons

[: breath on the back of our necks. It's just before us. Wake up and get

[: ready! Pastor Tom Hughes

[: ————————————————————————————

[: Please

[:

[: Take a moment and read

[:

[: Paul Harvey and Prayer

[:

[: Paul Harvey says:

[:

[: I don't believe in Santa Claus, but I'm not going to sue

[: somebody for singing a Ho-Ho-Ho song in December. I

[: don't agree with Darwin, but I didn't go out and hire a

[: lawyer when my high school teacher taught his theory

[: of evolution.

 

Maybe not, but then nobody attacked your teacher and had him put in jail for teaching evolution, but that has happened thanks to Xians, who just happen to be that majority. Xians have been attacking scientists in this and many areas, but most forcefully with this, beginning with the Scopes trial (when they did hire a lawyer at taxpayer expense) (and this is not to overlook the likes of Galileo and all of us whom you burned at the stake. We have a frightening history at the hands of Xians that you cannot expect us to overlook). Xians reap the benefits of evolutionary theory and evolution as fact applied to medical practice, then turn around and attack them.

What do they offer to explain DNA and genetics in a better way than evolution?—and how does it get applied to make medical advances even more accurate? Most certainly not Intelligent Design. What great scientific discoveries have resulted from Intelligent Design?

It explains nothing, and it leaves out most of the tangible evidence, and avoids most of the scientific discussion, in order to promote its claims. It is not even a theory, but is only an opinion.

 

[:

[: Life, liberty or your pursuit of happiness will not be

[: endangered because someone says a 30-second prayer

[: before a football game.

 

True, if someONE says a prayer, it affects nothing. If a whole stadium voluntarily prays, it affects nothing. When a whole captive audience is made to say a forced prayer attached to a certain religion, it is wrong and immoral no matter what because it removes freedom of religion from that place and accomplishes nothing but an show of arrogant force that does not serve the causes and interests of religion.

 

[:

[: So what's the big deal? It's not like somebody is up there

[: reading the entire book of Acts. They're just talking to a

[: God they believe in and asking him to grant safety to the

[: players on the field and the fans going home from the game

[:

[: "But it's a Christian prayer," some will argue.

[:

[: Yes, and this is the United States of America, a country

[: founded on Christian principles. According to our very

[: own phone book, Christian churches outnumber all others

[: better than 200-to-1. So what would you expect-somebody

[: chanting Hare Krishna?

 

This whole sentiment is based on an outright lie. Our first six presidents were deists. They believed in a god who created the universe and then turned his back on it. Deists and atheists wrote the Declaration of Independence and the USA  Constitution. Deists and atheists founded America at a time when only 6% of the population were Xians. Those principles were in play centuries previous to Xianity's establishment by Constantine. I don't see how anybody could believe contrary lies in the face of all the information so easily and readily available to anybody near a library or Internet-enabled computer.

 

[:

[: If I went to a football game in Jerusalem,

[: I would expect to hear a Jewish prayer.

 

Right. This is what is called a red herring, beside perpetuating the lie that preceded it and driving it even deeper, and it also is what is called comparing apples to oranges.

 

[:

[: If I went to a soccer game in Baghdad,

[: I would expect to hear a Muslim prayer.

 

If I went to a soccer game in Baghdad, I would expect a suicide bomber to appear and blow his fellow Muslims up. America is NOT a theocracy, and so there is no comparison. If I went to a baseball game in America, I would expect to hear NO prayer because this is a secular country. Iraq was also a secular country (although theocratic and a dictatorship) before we went there to practice our brand of imposing our beliefs on other people, and it will be a theocracy after they get through with us. Maybe, then, they might even take up soccer?

 

[:

[: If I went to a ping pong match in China,

[: I would expect to hear someone pray to Buddha.

 

Red herrings, strawmen, however you want to call them, Buddhism began as an atheist religion, but has been subverted into forms that, I suspect, might actually perform prayers. Even so, they are not operating under the American secular constitution and that is why this is a red herring argument.

 

[:

[: And I wouldn't be offended.

[: It wouldn't bother me one bit.

[: When in Rome ..

 

When in Rome, do as the Catholics do, right? I have read an argument once that the Vatican does run our government, but it was countered by an opposing argument that claimed Israel does. Who's to know? Oy, vay!!! This place is getting fishy with red herrings that have nothing to do with what goes on in the United States.

 

[:

[: "But what about the atheists?" is another argument.

[:

[: What about them?

 

Yep. Can't leave the moral, well-behaved and high in rectitude people out.

 

[: Nobody is asking them to be baptized. We're not going to

[: pass the collection plate. Just humor us for 30 seconds. If

[: that's asking too much, bring a Walkman or a pair of ear

[: plugs. Go to the bathroom. Visit the concession stand.

[: Call your lawyer!

 

Where are you passing that collection plate? What does that have to with anything? What is its purpose? Are you taking up for aid to hurricane victims? Somebody whose family lost everything? Somebody got cancer and can't afford a doctor? A new cross for the missing idol that got blown off your church? It makes a difference, you know?

I would contribute if I trusted those doing it, and their cause seemed just. By the way, according to your own Bible, aren't you the ones who Jesus bade to go to the bathroom, a closet, or some other private place and stop acting like hypocrites and republicans who insist on praying where others can see how pious they are?

 

[:

[: Unfortunately, one or two will make that call. One or

[: two will tell thousands what they can and cannot do.

[: I don't think a short prayer at a football game is

[: going to shake the world's foundations.

 

A complete, made up scenario about something I never have heard of happening. Another red herring. Does this guy not have any facts to work with? He has things backward on top of it, unless he counting one or two Xians who are trying to tell the whole rest of the world how to live.

 

[:

[: Christians are just sick and tired of turning the other

[: cheek while our courts strip us of all our rights. Our

[: parents and grandparents taught us to pray before

[: eating; to pray before we go to sleep.

 

An outright lie. All the way around. No one tells you to not pray before eating and sleeping, if that's what you believe is necessary. The courts are not stripping any rights away from any Xians; the courts have been active in preventing immoral Xians from stripping away rights from people of other religions, especially when Xians have persisted at placing their idols where they don't belong, at forcing Xian prayers at governmental activities, and at forcing Xian phrases to be spoken in front of graven images. Telling us to leave if we don't like it does not make anything about it any less immoral and wrong, nor any less unconstitutional.

And, go ahead and turn the other cheek. You have to, like it or not. It's your boss's orders.

 

[:

[: Our Bible tells us to pray without ceasing. Now a

[: handful of people and their lawyers are telling us

[: to cease praying.

 

An outright lie. If Paul Harvey, Sr said that, I would be amazed.

 

[:

[: God, help us.

[: And if that last sentence offends you,

[: well ... just sue me.

 

Lies always offend me. You don't like that? Sue me!

 

[:

[: The silent majority has been silent too long. It's time we

[: let that one or two who scream loud enough to be heard

[: .... that the vast majority don't care what they want. It

[: is time the majority rules! It's time we tell them, you don't

[: have to pray; you don't have to say the pledge of allegiance;

[: you don't have to believe in God or attend services that

[: honor Him. That is your right, and we will honor your

[: right. But by golly, you are no longer going to take our

[: rights away. We are fighting back ...

[: and we WILL WIN!

 

Are you striking your own face? That's what your complaints look like from here.

Okay, so your biblical story of the end times tells how this is all expected to end. Just like the illogical advancement of that whole paragraph, you are working to prevent what you believe is going to occur from happening?-- even though your source book says it's inevitable?

Depending on whom you read, the so-called silent majority is somewhere between 8 and 16% of Americans, about equal to the number of atheists. The actual majority wonders what all the squabbling is about, and why some people think it's so important. Xians lie when they claim anyone is taking their rights away, when they are whom others and other Xians are defending themselves against. Must we forever tolerate the hateful, belligerent antisecularism of a minority even among your own kind?

But, what is important to know is that America is not a democracy (except for politicians who have much to gain from misstatements); America is a constitutional republic (read the pledge if you don't have it memorized) and was set up that way to keep the majority from stomping all over the rights of minorities. If the author of this message attributed to Paul Harvey were half as wise as he thinks he is, he would recognize that and be working to defend his own rights against those who are actually working against him, and not the atheists who are bravely sticking their necks out to do work from which he'll benefit.

 

[:

[: God bless us one and all ... especially those who denounce

[: Him. God bless America, despite all her faults. She is still

[: the greatest nation of all.

 

And, secular, not Xian. Maybe that's why?

 

[:

[: God bless our service men who are fighting to protect

[: our right to pray and worship God.

 

Exactly, and also to protect our rights not to be forced into activities and rituals we don't believe in, for whatever reason we do not support that belief. Atheists can not denounce a god in which they do not believe, and it is illogical to think they can. If they do, they are believers, not atheists. We denounce those who spread lies under the name 'God'.

 

[:

[: May 2005 be the year the silent majority is heard

[: and we put God back as the foundation of our

[: families and institutions.

 

Actually, Muslims outnumber Xians world wide, and their stated goal is to turn the world into a uniform Islamic theocracy. I will likely be long gone by the time it occurs, but it will happen if Xians continue to attack people whose work actually benefits them at home, and side in with those who are working to overwhelm them.

 

[:

[: Keep looking up.

 

Yes, those birds are aiming more accurately lately. Here's to mud in your eye.

 

[:

[: If you agree with this, please pass it on.

[: If not . delete.

 

Right. Delete it and let it go unchallenged. Turn the other cheek. Do that like we are expected to, and then the Xians complain about the whirlwind they have stirred up in all their slapping. When debris from the whirlwind starts flying through the air, they accuse us of being the ones doing the attacking; whereas, if they would discontinue their slap-fest the winds would die down and stop getting things stirred up.

:8^) The Mad Poet, Lloyd

"Xian CumBax, a resource in support of atheists involved in the battle brought to them compliments of the Unworld Xian Soldiers. Updated often, with a lot of help from those it is designed to help." http://www.atheistlloyd.com/Debunking/CumBax.html


[Visit Kahli]  

 

What's religion really all about?

Read the Complete Universe of Memes http://tinyurl.com/3ckvfl 

 

This page last edited on 01/19/2008 

TNT-The Naked Truth Web Site
BUY a BOOK

Site Map Menu Page Back to Top Debunking Your request for Support? Glossary

YOU can SAVE A LIFE

This site is the responsibility of its author and none other. Unless otherwise noted, all information, graphics and displays, in their original and all updated forms, are copyright ©2002-2008 by Lloyd Harrison Whitling. To read permissions, click here. Your comments/complaints may be used in future web pages, discussion, group messages, or as examples within future articles without seeking permission, unless each message contains an explicit disclaimer of permission, without notification to you. Submit to

WANTED: Positive comments to be used in promotional materials. Constructive criticism of any kind is always appreciated. Negative (destructive) criticism without merit is also appreciated for its usefulness as humor, or as bad examples, examples of fruitless endeavors, and as sources of information for development of rejoinders. Threats will be taken as serious and turned over to appropriate agencies, as will obvious scams and other attempts to defraud, embezzle, etc.